Pilgrim’s Inn is always happy to hear what our guests have to say! We strive to make our bed and breakfast a home away from home while you’re in Deer Isle. See what our guests have to say about their experiences at our inviting Deer Isle Inn, then come and see for yourself! Check our availability, or contact us if you have any questions.

Perfect Maine Getaway

August 29, 2017The owners Nicole and Scott were charming hosts making you feel most comfortable, deliciously fed, and amongst lovely guests during our stay. We will return as soon as we are able to.

Wonderful Inn with Terrific Food and Service

August 07, 2017 We stayed for a few days in August and found everything about the inn delightful. Scott & Nicole set very high standards amid a cozy and relaxing atmosphere. All our meals were top notch, plentiful and delicious; so much so that some in our party ordered the same dinner meal the following night, which speaks for itself. Breakfasts were outstanding as well. Inn was comfortable, as was our room, and surprisingly quite for a fully occupied inn. Our party of four loved it.

Wonderful Place to Stay on Deer Isle

July 30, 2017– We stayed with Pilgrim’s Inn for two nights in late July, 2017. The owners Nicole and Scott were gracious and extremely accommodating. The property, set in a 1790s original home on Deer Island, is an absolutely peaceful setting for a couple days away from life’s craziness. Please give them a chance if your travels take you to Deer Isle.

Best and Most Beautiful Inn

July 31, 2017The historic house is beautifully kept as an inn. The bed was comfortable and the linens fresh and crisp. The gardens are lush and bird life plentiful. In addition the staff picked herbs used in the kitchen and the flowers on the table. Dinner was just lovely.

Above and Beyond

August 15, 2017The entire staff went above and beyond to make out stay “outstanding ” I understand now why you need to make dinner reservations 2-3 days in advance.

A Charming Inn

September 2017– A historic Inn with all the charm that goes with that. The owners are an wonderful couple who work hard to satisfy all your needs. Got to go back for a longer stay…


June 2017– The location is spectacular; the rooms lovely. The owners are friendly and so accommodating! The food was fantastic! The entire experience was very enjoyable on every level.

Check Availability