What Are Some of the Best Restaurants in Blue Hill, Maine?

While the natural beauty of the region might be the main draw to Downeast, it’s no secret that the culinary scene wins over the hearts of visitors as well! The best restaurants in Blue Hill, Maine are just a hop, skip, and a jump away from Deer Isle and Pilgrim’s Inn. Maybe you’re looking to grab a quick bite to eat on your way to explore the area. Perhaps you and your sweetheart want to make dinner reservations for a romantic evening. Whatever it is you’re craving, you’re bound to find the delicious food in Blue Hill! Continue reading for some of our favorite dining establishments, and access our Vacation Guide for more great suggestions to add to your Downeast itinerary!

The Best Restaurants in Blue Hill, Maine

Arborvine Restaurant

If you’re in search of the perfect romantic dinner destination, look no further, Arborvine Restaurant. Sit beside cozy fireplaces and revel in an intimate evening. Then, indulge in delicious meals, expertly prepared by an outstanding staff. Treat yourselves to creative, locally-sourced dishes ranging from bagaduce oysters on the half shell to a roasted rack of lamb served with oyster mushrooms.  

Marlintini’s Grill

A visit to Marlintini’s Grill makes an excellent addition to your list of things to do in Blue Hill! Share laughs over dinner in this relaxed and casual setting. Order the haddock chowder to start. Then, opt for a juicy burger, seafood basket, or a plate of shrimp scampi as your entree! You might even enjoy a chilled glass of craft beer to wash it all down!

The Harbor House Cafe

The Harbor House Cafe serves delicious sandwiches and salads that make for the perfect lunch before a hiking adventure in Blue Hill! Sit in the tea room and sip on hot apple cider paired with a homemade donut. Maybe you’d rather grab a seat outside to enjoy a slice of roasted veggie quiche with a side of seaside views. Visitors and locals alike love this charming cafe and its delicious, fresh food!

Fish Net

No coastal New England village is complete without a seafood restaurant that serves lobster rolls. There’s no denying that Maine’s fresh lobster is about as good as it gets, when talking about seafood. Stop in the Fish Net for chowder, fried clams, bacon-wrapped scallops, and more!

The Thurston Co.

The Thurston Co. restaurant is one of the newest dining establishments in Downeast. Enjoy delectable dishes such as baked squash stuffed with chevre, succulent lobster, and fried chicken served with biscuits and gravy. In addition to delicious food, guests can enjoy beautiful views of the water from the window!

Stay at Pilgrim’s Inn

room 6 pilgrim's innWhether you’re in town for a beach day or a visit to the Blue Hill Harvest Festival, you have to try one of the best restaurants in Blue Hill! After a busy day exploring the region, return to Deer Isle and stay in the best accommodations in Downeast at Pilgrim’s Inn! Visitors fall in love with our gorgeous property. Enjoy a quiet stroll around our tranquil mill pond and let the sense of serenity soak in. Room Six exudes an air of casual elegance through hardwood furnishings and allows for unparalleled views, right from your bedroom window. Start planning your dream vacation today!


Check Our Availability